03-17-11, 10:58 AM | #1 |
BassFishin.Com Member
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 14
|
graphite reel frames
Everywhere I go I here people talking about graphite in reel cosntruction and how it's absolute junk and should be avoided. I don't get this because I've ONLY fished graphite framed baitcasters and spinning reels ever since I started fishing. Well, half true. the only reels i've fished that have aluminum in the frames are 3 different fly reels that I moslty use for rare trout and occasional bass fishing. Most of my experience comes by way of two reels i've fished for years with no problems. 1) abu garcia silver max, and 2)shimano FX4000FD. i'm gonna try to ballpark the amount of time i've spent fishing each reels. Abu: 120-160 hours, Shimano: 250-300 hours. I fished with spinning reels for about 4-5 years when I was younger, but I changed to baitcasting, just because they feel a bit more ergonomic to me when palming the reel, and because I think they give me a little more versatility in my presentation.
I didn't fish as hard as I do now with my reels, so for the majority of this discussion, i'll refer to my experience with my Silver max. I done a lot with this reel, and fished in both fresh and saltwater. Most of the time though, i've just been bass fishing in a couple local lakes and ponds. about 80% of my bass have been pulled in with this reel. also a couple of flounder that I caught on a saltwater trip in new jersey. THis reel has been through a lot of hard hook sets, a few hard fights muscling flounder off the bottom, and pulling in a lot of salad and lily pads when I got my spinnerbait snagged or when a fish buried it self in salad. I'll start by saying that this reel has NEVER failed on me. I've never had a part break, or even felt or seen the reel flex. or had a problem with graphite frames ever. And that's all i've ever fished! I've also never had a problem with another baitcaster that i've fished a little longer in the salt with, the bass pro bionic plus (old version). as well as the shimano FX. Please chime in if anyone else has experience with graphite reels. |
03-17-11, 11:03 AM | #2 |
BassFishin.Com Veteran Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Superior, NE
Posts: 974
|
If they are working for you then don't worry about it. Bass fishing doesn't have to be a fashion show for people to enjoy it.
Having said all of that, I have seen graphite fail on the water. But, that was only one time. I think for most people they server the purpose well. |
03-17-11, 11:39 AM | #3 |
BassFishin.Com Active Member
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Milford,PA
Posts: 312
|
Just because Aluminum or magnesium may be stronger doesn't necessarily mean graphite is bad. The higher end reels don't use graphite due to it's flex which is not conducive to the tighter tolerances.
__________________
Visit us at www.delawarevalleytackle.com |
03-17-11, 12:10 PM | #4 |
BassFishin.Com Member
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 14
|
I totally agree with everything you guys say. And I have no doubt that the aluminum reels are stronger and will be more durable, but I still wonder why some people feel like they have to bomb graphite reels because they're not what they're used to, or because they had one problem or another.
But I feel that 100% of graphite reels will not perform just like MY silver max. there are probably some that might perform better, or worse. All i'm saying is that I have a system that works for me, and that just fine and dandy. there's nothing wrong with that. I just don't get how some people think that because something doesn't work for them specifically, they feel that it won't work for everyone. |
03-17-11, 12:20 PM | #5 |
BassFishin.Com Active Member
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Milford,PA
Posts: 312
|
Some folks are just rabid about brands, styles or whatever they think is best. I've had people tell me GMC pick-ups are the bomb but Chevy Silverado sucks. How can a pair of emblems accomplish that?lol
__________________
Visit us at www.delawarevalleytackle.com |
03-17-11, 12:32 PM | #6 |
BassFishin.Com Member
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 14
|
I guess some people are just biased and feel like one company or another is best and everyone else sucks, or won't give whatever product a fair look or opinion just because a certain company makes it. Kind of like the attitude that Cold steel knives has or maybe G Loomis trying to justify a 150$ 5'4" light action spinning rod as a "good cheap rod" just because it has the G Loomis name on it.
I've held some of the higher end GL's (not sure of model name, but I think they were around 295$) and they don't feel any better than my field and stream Tec Spec flipping stick (Awesome rod by the way!) which ran me about 60$! or the St. Croix triumph which ran 10$ more than the F and S! Last edited by unbiased14; 03-17-11 at 04:43 PM. |
03-17-11, 02:42 PM | #7 |
BassFishin.Com Super Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Okemos, MI
Posts: 1,447
|
I think it's all about keeping up with the Jones'. Some people like to have nice things to look at and use once and awhile. Me, I like to have nice things because I know that they are going to take a beating and I'll spend extra $ knowing that it will last longer.
|
03-17-11, 04:49 PM | #8 |
BassFishin.Com Member
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 14
|
Like for fashion. I guess they think "What's it style is all that'll work."
I just like stuff that works. It doesn't matter to me what's in style or not. I am a believer in split grips though; but that doesn't mean i'll bomb rods with regular grips. I just think that there are pros and cons to each design. |
03-17-11, 06:52 PM | #9 | ||||
BassFishin.Com Premier Elite
|
Quote:
I don't believe most people think that what works for them will work for everybody. But when asked for their opinions, I'm sure everyone will share their experience. You asked what's so bad about graphite reels, and I'm sure some people have had some bad experiences. That shouldn't be interpreted as them assuming it won't work for you, it's just them sharing their experiences to answer your question. Quote:
Quote:
Until you get some time on the water fishing a G Loomis, or other higher end rod, please don't tell me that they feel no better than your $60 F&S rod. They say ignorance is bliss, maybe it is... Quote:
I'd also like to know what you mean by you're a believer in split grips? You believe they reduce the weight of the rod on the wrong side of the fulcrum or you believe they're purely aesthetic? What is it about them you believe? Finally, I'd like to challenge you to go out and buy a good rod and reel combo. (If you can't, find a fishing buddy who will let you use theirs for a day). Then I'd like you to tell me the that it's no better than your Silver Max and F&S rod. Now so you don't take this the wrong way, I'd like to point out the fact that I'm not saying your combo doesn't work for you. It just seems to me like you're saying that higher end stuff, just because it may not work for you (or perhaps you just don't want it to), other's shouldn't use it either. Now I'm a strong believer in the fact that a person's money is theirs and it's none of my damn business how they spend it. So if you're happy with your combo, that's fine. I would still recommend trying to get some on the water time with some higher end gear, because like I always tell people: It's hard to go backwards! BB
__________________
As of June 14, 2014 the members of the BF.com forum have moved to basschat.yuku.com! |
||||
03-18-11, 04:27 PM | #10 |
BassFishin.Com Active Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Iron Mountain, MI
Posts: 174
|
Lets say for the record that I buy only aluminum body, rotor, etc reels. I can't say that the reels with graphite body, rotor, are lousy. It would just make sense the metal body would be built better. I just prefer not to take a chance. The price difference between a
aluminum reel ang a graphite body aren't really that much. Take a reel like Bass pro's PQ baitcasting reel 79.00 on sale and a Silver max, I'm guessing 59.00. Is 20.00 worth peace of mind? Maybe graphite will hold up the same, mabe not. For 20.00, I'm not going to take a chance. It would be my luck to have a fish of a life time lost because of a reel breaking down. By the way my son started on a graphite body spinning reel and still has it many years later! |
03-18-11, 04:35 PM | #11 |
BassFishin.Com Super Veteran
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 1,030
|
I´ve owned graphite frame reels and all of them broke on accidents, I don´t mean they didn´t work, I mean they broke, I had this Slistar BC reel I liked very much, one day while in the process of placing it on the rod it slipped from my hand and fell waist height ( and I ain´t THAT tall ) on the floor, landed on the reel foot and it broke, a piece of the foot was lost and the frame cracked. Also I had a Shimano Sedona, my compadre stepped by accident on the foot and it broke. Both reels after that were useless.
If my Silstar were aluminum frame that accident would most probably end with a bump on the reel foot and not a breakeage, why ? cuz I´ve dropped by accident other reels and that´s what happened. As for the Sedona, I bet that the most that could have happened after my compadre stepped on it would have been a bent reel foot. So, no more graphite frame reels for me. |
03-19-11, 06:29 AM | #12 |
BassFishin.Com Super Veteran
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Louisville, KY
Posts: 1,119
|
I have an Abu Garcia Maxxar reel that was about a $30 reel when it was purchased in the mid 90's. It is graphite, has been absolutely abused, and still goes fishing with me all the time. I have never seen first hand evidence of aluminum frames being superior to graphite frames. However, I have a new Pro Qualifier I paid about the same amount for as I did my Abu Pro Max. Ignoring the frame material, for the same price range, the PQ is 10x the reel. I dont buy reels based on what they are made of... i buy for performance, and aluminum frames just tend to be a byproduct.
|
03-19-11, 07:40 PM | #13 |
BassFishin.Com Active Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Farmersburg, IN
Posts: 341
|
I've got some and I've never had an issue with them. Never. That includes a trip out of the boat onto the asphalt at highway speed. One of them I would consider crap, but for the price I paid for it, I expect it to be crap. It flexes and I can feel it. The other ones I can't tell.
|
03-19-11, 09:14 PM | #14 |
BassFishin.Com Active Member
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 180
|
With the hours you mentioned, I would consider that recreational use. Their fine for that. Fish multiple tournaments a month and you'll feel a huge difference. Set the hook on an aluminum frame reel, and then on a graphite frame one and you'll feel the flex. Over the course of a hard day of power fishing cranks or spinnerbaits you'll feel it as well. Not to say their all that bad. But for the money you can spend 20-30$ more and get better reel that will last longer with less chance of failure. BPS has aluminum frame reels I believe for about $50 or less. I would say I probably fish close to 50 hrs a month avg and know guys that fish 100+ hrs a month. I wouldn't feel comfortable fishing all graphite reels at that pace. Bottom line, use what works for you.
__________________
Big gals always make us smile! |
03-19-11, 09:33 PM | #15 |
BassFishin.Com Super Veteran
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Dallas, TX
Posts: 4,671
|
All the graphite framed reels I ever owned started off as good reels, some of them very good. None of them made it longer than about a season though. I wasn't particularly hard on them but they definitely got used a lot. All of them suffered some sort of catastophic failure.
I found that buying a reel for $50 is way more expensive than buying a better one at twice the price. It is my experience that graphite framed reels don't last as long as aluminum framed reels.
__________________
There are 3 kinds of people in the world…those who can count and those who can’t. HRN4L |
03-19-11, 11:10 PM | #16 | |
BassFishin.Com Active Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Spring Lake, Michigan
Posts: 195
|
Quote:
|
|
03-20-11, 12:52 AM | #17 |
BassFishin.Com Super Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Wichita, KS
Posts: 2,427
|
I guess you could look at from this perspective, What is the benefit of graphite? I have thought about it and truly can't think of anything other than it may be a little lighter than aluminum reels in the same price point. I think the reason graphite reels get a bad rap is because they are typically reels on the very low end of a lineup. I am sure they have their place in the market, but it seems that they offer no real benefit to date. It would be interesting to see a company make a very high end graphite reel and see how it would be received.
__________________
They call me Ishmael |
03-20-11, 07:29 AM | #18 | |
BassFishin.Com Premier Elite
|
Quote:
BB
__________________
As of June 14, 2014 the members of the BF.com forum have moved to basschat.yuku.com! |
|
03-20-11, 09:11 AM | #19 | |
BassFishin.Com Active Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Sacramento, California
Posts: 483
|
Quote:
We have a friend called YAK, he's huge, we tride to see if he could snap a president off at the handle ,while attached to the rod, something he has done to 2 other reels., couldnt do it. I would say that Daiwa and Okums spinning reels, also of graphite stnd up b/c those are also used a lot around here, without major oncerns, most with graphite bodies Maybe when a pro or two endorses one, the rest of the sheep heard will follow,GEEZZ!!!!!!! These concerns are usually started in print, by advertisers and become what the fishing world repeats and believes. As far as Baitcasting, I have no opinion, as the reels I have used,Mostly Trions and Extremes, have all been Aluminum, so no opions here on those Last edited by Ebbetsguy; 03-20-11 at 09:17 AM. |
|
03-20-11, 09:36 AM | #20 |
BassFishin.Com Premier Elite
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Huntsville, Al
Posts: 7,466
|
When you see a car with lots of plastic trim, what do you think? Some might say "oooh space age materials for high weight to strength ratio" but most people say that the manufacturer is saving money with cheaper processes.
That is what you get with graphite in baitcasters, and from my experience it is justified. All a graphite frame means is that it is a less expensive reel, and less expensive reels are more likely to break. That doesnt mean that for a while they dont work, or if you keep the hours down they will stay in shape. You get what you paid for (which isn't a bad thing, $50 buys you some decent performance these days, just dont expect it to outlast an Abu reel and you will be satisfied). One last thing; it is not a marketing ploy implanted by advertising execs when people are wary of lesser grade materials. Mechanical experiences with failure naturally condition people to expect less from lesser quality - no marketing needed.
__________________
Selling live waterdogs for less since 2005. |
03-20-11, 10:04 AM | #21 |
BassFishin.Com Active Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Sacramento, California
Posts: 483
|
I could have sworn, I was speaking about spinning reels, not baitcasting. As you know ,unlike many I do not pretend to speak about what I do not know from first hand observation
wait , what's the last line I wrote Lets see now, copied and pasted for viewing accuracy: As far as Baitcasting, I have no opinion, as the reels I have used,Mostly Trions and Extremes, have all been Aluminum, so no opions here on those Oh I was right I did write about graphite spinning reels whew got confused there for a minute Last edited by Ebbetsguy; 03-20-11 at 10:10 AM. |
03-20-11, 10:19 AM | #22 | |
BassFishin.Com Super Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Wichita, KS
Posts: 2,427
|
Quote:
The Nano Shield technology that Abu is using, or one similar may hold the answer to producing high end graphite based BC reels. But for now, most anglers that prefer to use the upper end offerings of BC reels typically use sideplate material as one of the criteria to help determine quality of the reel. Regardless, I will continue to fish BC reels made from one of the many aluminums until they are no longer available.
__________________
They call me Ishmael |
|
03-20-11, 10:33 AM | #23 | |
BassFishin.Com Veteran Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Superior, NE
Posts: 974
|
Quote:
|
|
03-20-11, 10:35 AM | #24 |
BassFishin.Com Active Member
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Sacramento, California
Posts: 483
|
Fight??????
I was bustin on him for missing that There is no fight, you have to be less sensitive That whole reply was tounge in cheek Sorry if your having a Bad day |
03-20-11, 11:03 AM | #25 |
BassFishin.Com Veteran Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Superior, NE
Posts: 974
|
OK Muddy.
|
Disclosure / Disclaimer
Before acting on the content posted, you should know that BassFishin.Com may benefit financially and otherwise from content, advertising, links or otherwise from anything you click on, read, or look at on our website. Click here to read our Disclosure Policy and Disclaimer. |
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
|
|